Stage Analysis
Stan Weinstein's Time-Tested Method for Market Navigation
For financial advisors seeking to enhance their quantitative approach to investment management, Stan Weinstein's Stage Analysis method offers a powerful framework that complements momentum-based strategies. This systematic approach to technical analysis has stood the test of time since Weinstein introduced it in his influential 1988 book, "Secrets for Profiting in Bull and Bear Markets." Due to the complementary features of stage analysis and momentum investing, much of what you will learn in this blog is used to make communications from Tamarisk Research simpler.
Understanding the Four Stages of Market Cycles
Weinstein's genius lies in reducing market movements to four distinct stages that apply to individual securities, sectors, and broad markets:
Stage 1: The Base or Accumulation Stage
During this phase, a security moves sideways in a trading range after a downtrend. Key characteristics include:
Price consolidation within a horizontal channel
Decreasing volume as selling pressure subsides
Moving averages flattening after a downtrend
Institutional accumulation occurring quietly
For advisors, identifying assets in late Stage 1 can present optimal entry points, before the broader market recognizes the opportunity.
Stage 2: The Advancement or Markup Stage
This is the bullish phase when prices break out of their base after increasing volume. During Stage 2:
Prices reach higher highs and higher lows
Moving averages slope upward
Trade volume expands, particularly on upside moves
Relative strength improves against broad market indices
Stage 2 is where most investment gains are made, aligning perfectly with the principles of momentum investing.
Stage 3: The Distribution or Top Stage
Similar to Stage 1 but at elevated prices, Stage 3 represents a topping pattern, where:
Price movement becomes more volatile but remains within range
Trade volume increases on downside moves
Moving averages begin to flatten
Relative strength starts to deteriorate
Recognizing Stage 3 patterns allows advisors to reduce exposure before significant corrections occur.
Stage 4: The Decline or Markdown Stage
The final stage represents the bearish phase, when prices break down from Stage 3, characterized by:
Lower highs and lower lows
Downward-sloping moving averages
Increased trade volume on declines
Accelerating negative relative strength
Assets in Stage 4 should generally be avoided, aligning with absolute momentum principles that move to defensive positions during downtrends.
Implementing Stage Analysis in Portfolio Management
Weinstein's framework offers several practical applications:
Asset Selection Protocol
Creating a systematic screening process that:
Identifies securities transitioning from Stage 1 to Stage 2
Monitors existing holdings for signs of Stage 3 development
Establishes clear exit criteria when Stage 4 begins
Sector Rotation Strategy
Stage Analysis excels at identifying sector rotation opportunities. In time, Tamarisk Research will highlight a sector rotation strategy, based on dual momentum, that will:
Overweight sectors entering Stage 2 with the highest relative strength
Reduce exposure to sectors showing Stage 3 characteristics
Avoid sectors in Stage 4 entirely
Complementary to Dual Momentum
For advisors already using dual momentum strategies, Stage Analysis provides excellent complementary insights:
While dual momentum focuses on performance over specific timeframes, Stage Analysis adds structural context to price movements
Stage Analysis can help refine entry and exit points within a momentum framework
The visual nature of Stage Analysis makes it easier to communicate technical concepts to clients
Practical Client Communication
When presenting Stage Analysis to clients, emphasize these key benefits:
It provides a disciplined, rules-based approach to market cycles
The method has been validated across multiple market environments over decades
Stage Analysis helps remove emotional decision-making from the investment process
The framework offers a clear explanation for portfolio adjustments. Though the terms and stages may be foreign, they are simple to understand and learn. The goal is to allow for quick and easy communication over time.
Conclusion
Stan Weinstein's Stage Analysis provides financial advisors with a systematic method for identifying optimal entry and exit points across market cycles. Incorporating this approach into your quantitative investment process can enhance your ability to navigate changing market conditions while maintaining the disciplined methodology your clients expect from an institutional-quality investment manager.
For advisors committed to systematic investing frameworks, combining Stage Analysis with other quantitative approaches, like dual momentum, creates a robust framework that addresses both the cyclical and trending nature of financial markets. Future market updates from Tamarisk Research will reference stages when referring to assets, and this framework will allow quick and easy communication.
To download the PDF version of this blog post, click the button below.
Tamarisk Financial, LLC is a registered investment advisor dba Tamarisk Research. The advisor may transact business in states where it is appropriately registered, or where it is excluded or exempted from registration. Information presented is for educational purposes only and is not an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any securities or investment advisory services. Investments involve risk and are not guaranteed. Be sure to consult with a qualified financial adviser or a tax professional before implementing any strategy discussed herein.